HomeНовости и политикаRelated VideosMore From: Russell Brand

Tess Holliday - A Vacation From Body Shaming Or Modern Marketing? | The Trews [E454]

18059 ratings | 468661 views
Today's Trews discusses the controversy and hyperbole around Cosmopolitan featuring plus size model Tess Holliday on their October cover. What is the true motivation behind such a move? Unf*ck Yourself From The Modern World with my new book Recovery Get it here in US: http://tinyurl.com/ydcwz3kd Australia: https://t.co/Ri1XSonD2X UK: http://tinyurl.com/ycs8gu6b Listen to my Under The Skin podcast here https://itunes.apple.com/au/podcast/u... Subscribe to the my channel here: http://tinyurl.com/opragcg Produced & edited by Jenny May Finn Trews Music by Tom Excell & Oliver Cadman Trews Graphic by Ger Carney
Html code for embedding videos on your blog
Text Comments (4104)
skyv987 (1 hour ago)
Personally I agree with 'promoting' her body type on magazines and acceptance and all that shit. We should all have absolutely fuck all to say about anyone else's body or even their bad habits. It's no one's business. If someone is fat and feels good, let them. The only thing I will say is that these role models, magazines etc shouldn't ever be promoting that extreme obesity can be healthy. It's not. But that's a separate thing. Actually promoting a non-judgemental attitude toward fat people is more likely to help than hinder weightloss. The current default of society is still to depress the fuck out of fat people by treating them like dogshit.
Ciara McGuirk (1 day ago)
Wow spoken so well ❤️
The Unseen Eye (3 days ago)
I always get confused between you and Coogan
Momther Of Dragons (3 days ago)
I have to admit.. I thought you were just some weird celebrity that had nothing remotely interesting to say.. I was wrong. You laid this out and spoke kindly but truthfully. Very refreshing.
alex davidson (4 days ago)
Good video...made me think more than normal
Chris S (6 days ago)
I completely agree, General Zod.
Heather Comeaux (6 days ago)
How's that body positive? That's body destroying! Diabetes, hypertension, heart attack, stroke, the list goes on- of you want to have that much fat packed between the muscle and skin! This is not healthy!
WadeInnRoad (6 days ago)
You are so introspectively intelligent. I have never heard someone so honestly dishonest, so funny, so sharp, so accepting, so clear, so biting, so free to admit his frailties and to point out the stupidities of others. I love you, Russell. ♥️🤘🏻🤘🏼🤘🏽
emily_god6.9 (8 days ago)
I didn't think it was possible but he just got like a million percent hotter
emily_god6.9 (8 days ago)
When did Russell Brand get a YouTube channel 😂👌
Liza Tanzawa (8 days ago)
Well, fat poor people ARE the fastest-growing demographic in crony capitalist countries
Rikavari (9 days ago)
That 🎥 I feel Pretty, is a Must see!!!
Sound Evolution (10 days ago)
beautifully spoken .... well done.
Franklin Jerusha (10 days ago)
You have great skin
Square Inch (10 days ago)
I guess this means I get to 'celebrate' the scars all over me from a life-threatening illness. I guess we'll all act shocked when Tess dies of a massive coronary at 48. I guess unhealthy is the new healthy! Gotta love the meandering Brandian drivel, where he avoids taking a firm position on anything. I'm sick of this condescending, "You've forgotten how to connect" bs. It's not that he's wrong, but that wasn't what this video was supposed to be about. He should have spared us the sanctimony.
Natasha (11 days ago)
the point of the video is : DON'T let the mass media influence you in either way! just ignore Mass - Media and be yourself.
Night Owl (12 days ago)
You are spot on, I think if people are positive about themselves, that would make it easier to make healthier choices, and not feel like they have to hide behind closed doors. I think it’s hard to even go to a gym or do anything recreational if you feel like you aren’t accepted/
Stephen Goulding (13 days ago)
Russell brand is a pain in the arse white knight, and that is not beautiful
Eric Alexander (13 days ago)
This is the 'first' time I have enjoyed Russell speaking. A refreshing break from interrupting his guests and condemning the Elite.
Bartek Gałązka (14 days ago)
Russell, that kind of snake is called Ouroboros, as you propably know.
Kuumba Creations (14 days ago)
When did Russell brand become so well-spoken and have such profound ideas? Has he always been like this?
joanofarc33 (14 days ago)
She’s not a larger beautiful woman she’s an obese woman and having a pretty face while obese doesn’t change the fact that she’s morbidly obese. There. No commas or periods.
Johanna vdD (15 days ago)
Wow! He cut right through the bullshit and exposed the truth. Nicely done Russel!
outlawstars100 (15 days ago)
It's a load of bullshit because she is still photoshopped, if they wanted to be body positive they would include all the stretch marks and cellulite
Brian Marshall (15 days ago)
🤢🤮🤮 damn that’s fuckin disgusting
Angel Eyes (15 days ago)
Being a fat woman/man will NEVER be considered socially attractive or a desirable fashion trend. Grossly excessive fat is disgusting, unhealthy and unattractive. I figure if fat people want to flaunt their fat on magazine covers, then they should be able to handle the truth. Remember the days when people would pay to view the fat lady at the fair.
Paige Weiss (15 days ago)
“An artificial debate that exists primarily in the world of commerce...” Yes, just humans creating industries based on the thoughts and ideals of other humans. Making money off of creating ideals with which we choose to define ourselves. Kind of backwards as we are the primary ones to define ourselves since we are the ones in the end who are producing the thoughts running around in our heads. So I guess we just have to be careful about what information we choose to take in and process.
The Oceans Gaurdian (15 days ago)
Body positive is all a marketing gimmick, Tess has made millions being a professional victim and using emotional manipulation to clean out your wallets. She doesn't give 10 shits about the lowly pesents, she goes on and on about trolls she claims she doesn't care about so you feel sorry for her and buy more of her products. Nothing these models/sales people do is pure or honest, it all about her brand and bottom line.
Thank you, Russel. I agree with you on all accounts. What resonated with me most is what you what you said about connection. I do my best to assist people who want to make a deep connection to purpose. And as you said there is "no public utensil" that can do that for someone. This is something that resides in the person, their inner drive and stream of consciousness. And it is my humble opinion that we can best facilitate helping a person make a deep connection, one that will be unique to them, through what we perceive as the truth; truths that we have used to achieve success for ourselves. And if these truths have indeed been fruitful in our application of them to our own lives, then with a free conscience, given that we are willing to reassess that which we see as the truth and with a righteous sentiment attached to our actions-- consider it as our duty to attempt to share these truths with a receptive audience. And to do this without expectation of any type of reward is the real meaning of service.
Suzi Cameron (17 days ago)
Fat = unhealthy
Gillian M (17 days ago)
Body image is a huge issue for both sexes but being skinny and overweight doesn't make you feel happier. If people focus on the inner and not the outer the outer Body will follow. Heal the inner......reveal the true self
Secret Santa (17 days ago)
Why does it bother people so much? If you don’t like it don’t buy or look. Hahahahaha: I think she’s gorgeous. I like looking at different body shapes. It’s way more interesting😁
Dt Abyss (17 days ago)
Well said
Sheryl Smith (17 days ago)
Many fat / obese people are in shape and eat a lot healthier than slimmer people. Its just nice to see that I am ok to go out and walk around among you 'God' like 'normal' people who as you state are much healthier than I am and will never die as you say I will not live past 40 years. Please let me feel good about myself for a little while, and try to raise my head enough so I can see ahead of myself as I cannot see my toes...
vitriol or debate (17 days ago)
Body positivity is bad. It removes the peer pressure needed to promote fitness. Fitness being aspirational and efficient. As far as a society goes.
kreamy rhodes (18 days ago)
I just love what you have to say on this issue. You make me feel less crazy for questioning these notions of trends vs humanity. I'm sorry i just found your channel but I'm happy i did.
Kamina Manifesto (18 days ago)
Best take I've seen on this.
Pixie Snow (18 days ago)
I don't care what she does with her body or how big she is but why do the rest of us have to look at it and, worse yet, have to pretend like it's something 'beautiful'?
vitriol or debate (17 days ago)
If everything and everyone is beautiful we need a new word to describe things that are more desirable and attractive in appearance than average. Like the word actually-beautiful. Or something with more zing to it.
Kerry (18 days ago)
So the point is that the fashion industry and mainstream media isn't being genuine here. It doesn't care about the issue of body shaming. It is in fact responsible for it. It's revenue stream and whole basis for existence is centred around the undermining and comparing of women's bodies. The plus sized model story is just to perpetuate a false notion that the magazine has values but really it's another income stream. This time through shock and controversy, whilst inauthentically giving the appearance of having a value system supporting body positivity.
rash b (18 days ago)
Damn he made a profound point in the beginning about the problem being that we have a bad standard if we're attaching so much value to Cosmopolitan or the royal family. Hopefully more commentators will break things down on this wider perspective. We all get caught up in debating the main talking point.
EE RG (18 days ago)
I’m much happier when I’m a bit overweight than when I’m underweight and starving myself.
EE RG (18 days ago)
Better than an anorexic!
brianaaimee (18 days ago)
I like your very last comment about us needing community. I think this is lacking in my life and in so many people I know. I actively work at building community because it no longer just exists. I need to seek it, build it, nurture it because it's an important and intresic (sp?) part of being human. Thank you for sharing your thoughts on this blip of fake news Russell Brand.
rickenbacker40011 (18 days ago)
You raise a good point, for the good cosmo would do to change people’s perspectives on beauty with that cover I will accept. But it is true, the fact that people have already ingrained within them that they need an external source of validation to decide what they think is beautiful is the true issue. That someone searching for a mate needs other people to find the person they are pining for attractive and desired, for social capital. Capital is really the fearsome beast isn’t it.
I am truly impressed and refreshed by your views and commentary.. Subscribed keep it up
Rayan Agarm (19 days ago)
Like invented conversation..
Rayan Agarm (19 days ago)
2:14 smart yep..change those means..?ok
Rayan Agarm (19 days ago)
Ok mr russel...ive heard you long time ago...and yes a quick wit..lately. See tiny bits..and yes i thought he may be kinda smart..but after 1:37 i was right along no wrong...Fin ... just only brilliant... and is all merchandising yes..? Well donesaid Mr Brand.
Lee (19 days ago)
It seems intellectually dishonest to pretend that humans generally speaking don't have an innate concept of beauty that is to a large degree a product of genetic determination and evolution. It matters not what Cosmopolitan says, and you can't overcome the predetermined standard of beauty. The only path forward is to be ok with yourself KNOWING that you aren't beautiful by the standard. You can really be free if you can unshackle yourself from the idea that you need to redefine beauty so it includes someone like you in the definition.
enzo fortuna (19 days ago)
So if celebrating fat girls is ok,why isn't real skinny boney girl celebrated,the virtue signaling from the left is mind boggling,fuckin hipacrits
space cadette (19 days ago)
It really says something about this whole movement and issue when most other fat people completely disagree with this whole fat positivity movement and want for people who are fat to ignore the land whales saying it's ok to be a lazy fat waste of considerable space....
PINK CIRCLE (19 days ago)
Don't you dare say it runs in my family.
PINK CIRCLE (19 days ago)
I want this magazine to come out. Veganism. Eat lots of vegetables and never feel bad.
Mrs. Jones (19 days ago)
What he's trying to say is that it's beyond the obvious (that she's unhealthy) so stop stating it Sherlock, we got it. This is a different argument, listen.
Mariam Miranda (19 days ago)
Your comments about this topic about fat people being displayed in the media in my opinion is the most correct one. Its about "COMMERCE".
sparrowgirl 98 (19 days ago)
She isn't "chunky" or "plumpish". She is dangerously overweight.
VoiceULove (20 days ago)
Better question would be. Would GQ magazine ever do something like this? Well, they did, but apparently their "version" of a plus sized woman is 20 pounds overweight, lol.
Blujonny11 (20 days ago)
Some women are heavier and there's no loss of attractiveness in that. But this woman really seems to epitomize the type that appear on the biggest loser. The type of person who is by any definition a food addict in the same way a meth addict is addicted to meth.
burymedeep 2093 (20 days ago)
If she is body positive why does she lie so much about her size and weight? 280? Try 380 or more. Size 22? My girlfriend told me she is way past that. Her body is nasty
Quentinho King (21 days ago)
Didn't the body weight activist who spoke on TED talk ended up dying of a heart attack at the age of 34.
Super Sam85 (21 days ago)
Damn. Russell is playing chess and everyone else is playing checkers.
Sari L. (13 days ago)
YES!!
tills mcgills (21 days ago)
All these plus size models are just obese women with pretty faces that's it.
Douglas A Coleman jr (22 days ago)
I agree
Mike Stanmore (22 days ago)
'Nike' is pronounced 'Nye-Kee'! It's the name of the goddess of victory.
ririririPXN (22 days ago)
I love the raised interest in the cover of Cosmo since this obese model by men. I can only assume that either it destroyed their issue of Cosmo or are genuinely concerned about the unhealthy message to young and impressionable girls much to the contradiction of all the other very healthy messages Cosmo has been giving. Yes, I am being very sarcastic. But very...
hello sunshine (22 days ago)
We shame every other addiction except lazy obese assholes🤷‍♂️ Ya let’s encourage em instead of giving them accountability.
Alexander Tan (22 days ago)
I dont think Cosmopolitan has the right to shove this kind of image in people's face. When these image is put on magazine cover, you are forced to look at disfigured bodies.
Joy Lopez (23 days ago)
It's important to like ourselves-- period. There is only positives in Tess H. liking herself and being herself. A magazine, Cosmopolitan, increased the potential of their profits with this cover-- on that particular month. Curious what profits were? It isn't showfriends-- it's $howbu$ine$$. Thanks for speaking clearly about this subject, Russell Brand. ((Hugs))
jhunt5578 (23 days ago)
Why don't cosmo put a bulimia suffering anorexic on the cover with her skeleton showing and her eyes glazed over? Maybe because we shouldn't be body positive about clinically ill body shapes. But that logic has been overlooked with the morbidly obese Tess Holliday. Let's send a message to all the overweight and obese children out there, that a future of chronic disease and early death doesn't matter, because you can be beautiful just the way you are. ffs.
Thomas Kreisel (23 days ago)
Why did Russel Brand become a youtuber?
David Sim (23 days ago)
It would have been better to put a normal, average looking woman who is within her ideal BMI and run a story on why that is basically healthy. Lets be honest, she is not happy or fullfilled being that weight. She clearly has something going on in her life that she is escaping via food.
Swerveey (23 days ago)
The debate is the fact that already over sized women will be like "Oh so it's okay that I'm like this, I don't need to change any poor habits I might have". The issue isn't that average women will see it and go eat a whole pizza parlor. It's making already overweight women think that it is okay to be that large, even though they may be unhealthy. I could care less if a woman is fat, but putting her on the cover of one of the top beauty magazines is almost saying that being that large is acceptable from a health and wellness standpoint.
Paul Murphy (24 days ago)
God almighty this guy loves to hear the sound of his voice. They're six minutes of my life I'll never get back. I guess he has enough money now to just sit around contemplating his navel and commenting on Cosmopolitan covers. 6 1/2 minutes and not one time did this guy say this is a fat woman and she's unhealthy and she shouldn't be celebrated in any fashion. End of story!
Jaro (24 days ago)
It's not that I don't have a heart, but if you are that weight or size zero, I do not want you to feel positive about your body. I want you to feel positive about getting healthier, because I don't want you to die young.
Jaro (6 days ago)
+ariana moore Ok, I believe you. Perhaps size zero is being overused as a label for underweight when it shouldn't. My point was more about being dangerously underweight.
ariana moore (13 days ago)
Jaro I see this comment constantly and irks me to NO END. YOU CAN BE HEALTHY AT A SIZE ZERO. I am petite, barely 5 foot 1. I eat plant based meals three times a day, lead an active lifestyle and exercise regularly. I have worked hard to be healthy as I’ve been much skinnier and I was unhealthy. I’m a size zero and none of my bones stick out, and I’m actually a D or DD bra. Being THIN or SMALL is different than being anorexic. So saying someone is unhealthy because they are a size zero is just so stupid.
George Hartwell (24 days ago)
What is the reality of being a human being? Because there is a vacuum in our lives, we attach meaning to what is on the cover of Cosmopolitan Magazine and discuss it on social media. We are searching for meaning and purpose and acceptance of who we are. Which can be assisted by community.
maccajoe (24 days ago)
I dont give two shits if people want to be body positive IF ITS WITHIN healthy ranges. Which Tess is not. The West is literally as fat as its ever been. Diabetus, heart disease and a myriad of other diseases are as high as they have ever been and so is obesity. Its a fucking joke really.
RocksAnd Socks (25 days ago)
Impressive thoughtful commentary. Whole new level of respect. Good job.
Micah Stewart (25 days ago)
Marketing, how much of a hypocrite do you have to be to see every non shamed over weight person being covered in tattoo’s. Society can only accept fat people if they pass a certain visible ink to skin ratio. Make sense of that!! How about we stop glorifying people who are unhealthy and focus more on the bigots of the world who spread shame, jealousy and hatred as marketing tools in the first place. Which you cant due to the whole capitalist economy being based off coveting what your neighbour has. America, the “christian nation” that breaks every rule in its own book. Hypocrites from coast to coast.
L H (25 days ago)
Whether you find a certain magazine to be relevant is your choice. I have never felt that they held a power over me.
gamertv 46 (25 days ago)
I think the body positivity movement has gone to the extreme and now me being a woman who is in between a size 12 and 14 depending on where I shop I am healthy I have no pre-existing conditions I work out everyday and I love my size but I am also tall I love being thick I'm a black woman I want to be thick
Da Hogman (25 days ago)
Let the fatties pretend everything is ok. If they ignore Heart Disease, Diabetes, High Blood Pressure etc, it might just go away, right? Wait 30 years and the fatties will all be dead anyways. Problem is we are all paying for their health care....awesome
Fernando Tan (26 days ago)
They tend to confuse some caring people to be haters, but the truth is they are just hopeful she can get the benefits of being healthy and fit and to lose the many disadvantages of being obese. Some might have the same intention for her but just can't construct the right sentence to make it a positive thing.
Maiya O (26 days ago)
The more we accept women at whatever size they are, the easier it actually it is for them to become healthy.
CROWNONPOINT (26 days ago)
i fucking love u.
The Healing Woman (27 days ago)
If we are glorifying her then we equally need to glorify horrendously underweight women. Two extremes of the same disorder
Home Kitchen (27 days ago)
love  fat women ..
Soupy Chang (28 days ago)
She looks like sentient gravy.
fullblown mind (28 days ago)
Tess holiday is obese not plus size
ric vegas (28 days ago)
this lady isnt healthy, certainly not heathy like the lady with the long beard who made this video
Steven Winterhill (29 days ago)
Disgusting woman....more like lard with drawings on it...smh
MalcolmXParis (29 days ago)
Why are there NO Magazines or Movies of any kind trying to "hype" or showcase Scrawny or FatAss Men, or "Nerds" or "Wimps" Terms that women have used LIBERALLY for Years to demean Men yet nobody (least of all women) were whining or "concerned" about "body-shaming" then? No magazine would put some scrawny or fatass man on its cover and say - "Oh this is about putting an end to "Body Shaming". Nobody would buy It. What a crock of one-sided Bullshit!
LightYard (29 days ago)
lol she isnt even a size 22, more like a size 32.
Mattack (30 days ago)
There's nothing positive about obesity
American Robby (30 days ago)
I love Russell. What a great human being.
kfoster009 (30 days ago)
We should all strive to be as knowledgeable and smart as Russell.....
cipher88101 (30 days ago)
That magazine doesn't give a shit about her, she will be dead in 5-10 years from congestive heart failure regardless, but hey, had to do something to get that rag out of the doctor's waiting rooms didn't they? This isn't about her at all, it's about profit and the pandering it takes to make it.
Cynthia Lewis (24 days ago)
Exactly!
Imanu-el (1 month ago)
Would say that I agree with most things you said, but the only thing that I strongly disagree is your last word "Community". I don't think we reach to a higher and deeper understanding of who we are, by means of a Community. Yes, it's important to be and feel part of one, but we only reach inner peace and "nirvana" by individually accepting who we are, what we want and what purpose we want to establish in this world.
jessepoulter (1 month ago)
If we normalize being obese and start lying to them and ourselves about what healthy and what's not then the 50% "If not more" of people in the UK, USA, Canada, etc etc. Will not have a desire to be healthy. It's fucking sick and no diffrent than putting an anorexic women on the cover.
Buck Fuddy (1 month ago)
I'm 5'6, 110lbs, probably a "6" on my best day..where's MY cover?? Who are we average joes supposed to look up to?? Certainly not this slob, right??
Bradell McClain (1 month ago)
Facts, Russell gets it 👍🏽

Would you like to comment?

Join YouTube for a free account, or sign in if you are already a member.