HomeНовости и политикаRelated VideosMore From: Russell Brand

Is Fascism Back In Fashion? - Russell Brand & Yuval Noah Harari

2120 ratings | 87885 views
Russell Brand discusses why people might be drawn to fascism - a clip from Under The Skin with Yuval Noah Harari (Ep #049 - Our Are Children AI Slaves?) You can listen to the entire podcast episode on iTunes, Spotify or here: https://www.russellbrand.com/podcast/049-yuval-noah-harari-children-ai-slaves/ Subscribe to my channel here: http://tinyurl.com/opragcg Unf*ck Yourself From The Modern World with my new book Recovery Get it here in US: http://tinyurl.com/ydcwz3kd Australia: https://t.co/Ri1XSonD2X UK: http://tinyurl.com/ycs8gu6b Produced & edited by Jenny May Finn (@JennyMayFinn) Music: Oliver Cadman Graphic: Gareth Jones
Html code for embedding videos on your blog
Text Comments (1572)
Enzo Ferrari (5 days ago)
The dark side is seductive because it appeals to the ego. If evil were repulsive it would by definition through exclusion not be attractive. Doing what is good is hard because it goes against our very biological directive--self preservation Christ said, and through his life showed, that the greatest thing another man can do for his friends is lay down his life. To deny his own self. Christ says take up your cross and follow me. It is an appeal to do what is burdensome and self annihilating ----patadoxically, only then can the self be most sublimely realized.
Bruised Kimchi (14 days ago)
I don't think Russell brand understands much of anything here. Yuval and he are talking at cross purposes, one about logical arguments, the other about emotional rhetoric
Nate Andrews (15 days ago)
I personally appreciate the opportunities afforded to me in the process of being exploited, especially the one where I get to continue existing.
Michael (17 days ago)
Why did I wait and set on a path of wandering the comment sections of various Youtube videos before joining Russel's channel?
Rudi van Doornegat (22 days ago)
Why is my translation not available yet?
GremGreene (24 days ago)
Dope Channel Russ. That means good in hood talk.
NPC-752231 BBC (24 days ago)
At the end of the day people would rather have an authoritarian that listens and loves his/her people, rather than a totalitarian government that hates it's people. What differentiates our government from any other tyrannical government if they cannot act on the most basic result in a YES/NO vote. We are tired of not being listened to, and the fact that you are just cottoning on to this shows the blissful ignorance that the left has been living in.
S. F. (26 days ago)
Fascism feeds the ego and people who are susceptible to that need fall for it no matter what else it comes packaged with.
Danny 1488 (26 days ago)
berzubirze (1 month ago)
starting from minute 6 about beauty and seductiveness of darkness- so delicious... thanx!
Pete Peterson (1 month ago)
Muslims - fascists
sam333 (1 month ago)
i can't take a man with a silly beard like that serious, he's grown it lately to be more enlightened looking lol
laugh out loud (1 month ago)
The German uniforms for the Nazis in WW11 were specifically designed to appeal to the ego, to create a sense of superiority. The dark side always knows how to feed our insecurity.
Flora McDonald (1 month ago)
Yes fascism is back in fasion . Everyone wants a bit of it these days even the school kids talking about it. You cant even go in a supermarket these days without hearing someone say i like your new fascism
Wes Cragg (1 month ago)
Oh please...just bring in W.C Democracy and eliminate all the useless "ism's" that plague our society. Still waiting on your reply there Russ....yup, your a people and I'm a people, so let's do the talking... remember that line?
Mich S (1 month ago)
Fascism is a left wing, collective authoritarian ideology, it is to the right of communism and got labelled right wing by the communists, but in today’s world it’s on the left, communism, fascism, socialism all collective, on the right conservatism, classical liberal, libertarian, all individualism.
Σαμπλε Τεξτ (25 days ago)
Fascism is spectral-syncretic.
Robin Lynn (1 month ago)
I can not see earth as anything other than a good place to come and learn what you are not. It doesn't need fixed because it serves its purpose as it is. It is intended to be full of extreme experiences and everything in between because that is how it serves its purpose. Tom Campbells "My Big TOE" at least gives a more reasonable explaination as to why the most obviously insane ideas somehow manage to increase and flourish despite being excessively foggy, hazey and unfocused in form. They somehow manage to be given the status of "normal, good, necessary or even reasonable." We get hooked into this "fight or flight" seemingly perpetual way of being insane the minute we take it too seriously and believe in it. Pick your 'ism?
The Legend (1 month ago)
Fascism is a way of life. An ideology where you put the greater good of your nation and people before you. A mere cell in a greater organism. While the depressed individualist goes to work at a restaurant to make money, the fascist goes to work to feed his people. The fascist has purpose.
aronchai (2 days ago)
Eeew
brainsareus (1 month ago)
this fucking guest is annoying, he nit-picks and disagrees when there is no reason to.
stvmcr (1 month ago)
Capitalism is still the most fair
Come on, the Capitalist west FUNDED FASCISM, it still does, just look at Ukraine now, puppet nation of the Capitalist US to provoke and attack Russians, exact same thing they did with Nazi Germany, also in order to attack Russians, they want to destroy the Communist ideology, that is their real target, always was. This is not coincidence, this is intentional.
Alexander Storey (1 month ago)
God I wish Ukraine was fascist. But they are not. they are neo-liberal scum at best. They invoke no original Italian fascist teaching through controlled fascist cultural or political doctrines. Therebye they are not fascist
zyzz (1 month ago)
Lol, neither of these two gimps know what Fascism is.
zyzz (1 month ago)
Fascism is the future
zyzz (2 days ago)
+aronchai I lol at people who present shitty takes. Lol nigga
aronchai (2 days ago)
+zyzz Lol
zyzz (2 days ago)
+aronchai Fascism is rooted in the concept of "eternal struggle" you can never destroy fascism let alone ideologies
aronchai (2 days ago)
It's quite literally the past.
ioana ilea (1 month ago)
There is no perfect political stance or ideology. But we do have tragic ones we should stay away from unless we want even more suffering.
ioana ilea (1 month ago)
I don't know about fascism, but socialism surely is.
Jim Bowden (1 month ago)
Dumb FUCK Russell.....thinks he is an intellectual !!!!! Ha Ha Ha ha aaaaaaaaaaaaa
1005psomd (1 month ago)
I look Nordic and I want to preserve my genes, there is nothing wrong with that
aronchai (2 days ago)
Put your jizz in the freezer then
Kevin Mard (1 month ago)
Yes it is, starting with yuval's home country of Israel.
Matt Verville (1 month ago)
Fascism can be proven to be the most effective way to run a country and anyone who argues that just doesn't know enough or never looked into it. The problem is when you group fascism with being racist. Just because there are dogs that bite people doesn't mean all the dogs bite
Vic Tomised (1 month ago)
If you elect a globalist puppet politician that's apparently democracy. If you elect someone who stands up for their people, they are apparently fascists. I know which one I'd choose.
Diane (1 month ago)
Without compassion and love we will never have a fairer Society ever🙏🇬🇧
Steg Sjenga (1 month ago)
Fascism is capitalist Russell. Just look at Bolsonaro.
jim crow (2 months ago)
Fascism is the conservative backlash. Everyone dreads the conservative backlash. Skinheads are a conservative backlash. Avoid the conservative backlash, stop pushing people around.
dan taylor (2 months ago)
Waste of 9 minutes the answer is yes, go outside see it for yourself.
Charlie Bunt (2 months ago)
Brand is just arguing for points and has no clue. He comes across as a total idiot with no care
Matthew Schuster (2 months ago)
End the vilification of Trump supporters and end the attack on whites as best means to bring on the Fascism to come is a system in place (as now, thanks to Democratic President Obama on December 31, 2011 gave the citizenry inability to be safe from a Hard right authoritarian, now we have criminal reform to give final part of means to create mass extermination of native tribal nations of Americans the racist calls native or Indian and then also African American poor and the poor white for unity) taken and brought forth with a welcoming to those losing power (more the illusion of ever having power by forgetting the history of class, unions, American socialism, Marxism, Civil war, poor whites in the south, Anarchy, etc); as, whites hurt in a middle class tradition weakened to broken, as all those feeling like the worst are up lifted by the one they see as a father who will keep them safe, make them feel special and awesome, and take from the weaker hated more powerless minority group. The enemy of a loved emotional leader, is seen not caring, for their humanity stripped away. Made criminal is ways of which worst attitudes grow into moral decay. Moral decay starts when morality is never relative or non existing, culture is superior as fact justifying lost humanity and pride in cruelty, as morals twisting is done using fear. The psychopaths using fear, looking strong, is moral cause that people who support the state and a single party for the state and private owner of nations fate, in getting rid of those no different in being a kind loving human being, is An Antichrist God of illusion to rational people that simply vanish.
What the fuck????
Ellar Marina (2 months ago)
I luv his accent!😂
Civisme Secret (2 months ago)
GAZ CHAMBERS FOR JEW RUSSEL NOW !!
Well the obvious reason why there’s a bunch of right wings slagging of the left and calling them fascist is because they’re fascist themselves and we’re attracted to the title of it coming into fashion
odinsmeadhorn (2 months ago)
Yes, and it's about damn time... I kid, I kid!
jon hamm (2 months ago)
Hitler was the greatest leader of the past 500 years. One reason he obtained to Time magazine cover in the 1930's was for his economic miracle- turning Germany around after thorough collapse by jewish Marxists in the Weimar republic. His greatness is being rediscovered and appreciated. An artist-wanderer turned messiah- a real life story every bit as good as Ridley Scott's "Gladiator" #TGSNT
shadfurman (2 months ago)
Fascism is authoritarian national socialism. Bernie Saunders is fascist.
Troy Walker (2 months ago)
agreed, to demons, heaven is hell, and hell is heaven.
Troy Walker (2 months ago)
no. the exploited worker can always be replaced. thats why the rich create poverty, to keep the world full of whores and soldiers
Alex and the monsters (2 months ago)
interesting talk
Soren Johannesen (2 months ago)
IF YOU KEEP FEARING THE POWER OF YOUR SPIRIT AND KEEP REJECTING AND DENEING YOUR EMOTIONS THEN YOU WILL KEEP CHOOSING OUT OF BALANCE BELIEFS AND CHOOSE ONE OF TWO ROLES, SLAVE OR SLAVE MASTER
John Soft (2 months ago)
Canada is totally in the grips of "corporate fascism".Trudeau is a fascist pig. Cheerio!
zyzz (1 month ago)
"Everyone I don't like is a Fascists"
FoodieOnTour (2 months ago)
Russel, listen for once!
VALIANT JOKER (2 months ago)
EVERYTHING HAS PURPOSE THERE IS A DIVINE REASON FOR SKIN COLOUR. THE PROBLEM IS WHEN PEOPLE THINK ONE COLOUR IS SUPERIOR TO ANOTHER...A HUMAN ONLY EXCELS ANOTHER HUMAN BY THEIR SELFLESS GOOD DEEDS AND ACTIONS REGARDLESS OF SKIN COLOUR. WE ARE GATHERED HERE TO GET THINGS RIGHT!
Liber 8 (2 months ago)
Russell Brand = UTTER HYPOCRITE!!! Has a net worth of $15,000,000 but still tries to portray himself as 'one of the people' He talks about the ELITE without ever acknowledging that HE IS PART OF THE ELITE!!!
Harry Wolf (2 months ago)
Virtue signalling vs an opinion.
I Kill Everything I Fuck (2 months ago)
To get an idea of what the comments are like, just stick your head in a trash can 👌
zyzz (1 month ago)
Pussy
Sidney Raboflatz (2 months ago)
Fascism was Left of Center, a competitor to Communism, that is why The USSR and Germany were such hated enemies. Mussolini was a Left leaning Fascist, joining with Hitler...
Mark Alan (2 months ago)
Kabbalistic Teachings are the original fascists!
Brian McEverybody (2 months ago)
The answer is yes, judging by the comments
mojopin 70 (2 months ago)
Political correctness is fascism pretending to be kind/manners.
REDDRAKON (2 months ago)
Hitler was very sincere but history is written by the winners.
oyvey (2 months ago)
the white man realises that fascism is the best system for the worker to organise in.
T7 (2 months ago)
I’m surprised Russell isn’t making more excuses for mohammedan rape gangs:) That’s a favorite hobby of Russell’s. English people literally care more about the welfare of foxes and jihadis than their own children:)
Ziggy’s Revenge (2 months ago)
It’s back because people are seeing documentaries such as https://youtu.be/9ZBfEcQgULI Which provide factual evidence proving what we are taught in history books and at school are a lie, that both world wars were to benefit rich men and to create Wall Street and enable sweat shops and slavery to be continued while shutting down western industries... all our grandfathers and fellow countrymen caught against one another for NOTHING. We’re now seeing the affects of the wars and everything they fought to defend has been a lie also. Every country is screwed and the Elite banksters and so fourth benefit from our hard earned wages, where we can barely afford a thing and our kids are raised by the school system. we have no family interest and are forced to believe that multiculturalism is a good thing when it forces one culture to not express there’s and the other to push there’s in the others face... when really we are all diverse and need space. Our kids all turn out to be fuck ups, our food is over priced and taxes, fuel, healthcare, finance, the rise of homelessness is never ending. ‘the war on drugs’ ‘terrorism’ is a fucking global joke as we basically find all the terrorists or were once allies and stab them in the back, invade some poor fuckers country and bleed their country dry if all natural resources and just move on to the next beautiful country and destroy it all to find our vile system of filth. politicians do t give a shit and divide the people for 1 and make money and cause wars but don’t fight in them.. our countries are full of crime, murder, half the rich men who do run the world are weird demon worshippers or paedopholes... our whole system is fucking disgusting. and it was very different 70 years ago. I think people need to wake up to be honest, start doing some more research from both sides of the story before commenting and then realising that we’re stuck in the mud and aren’t progressing. They hide technologies that can clean our planet and give clean water to all, they force the people against one another and cause all wars which cause us to fight in the first place.. and you know what. WE THE PEOPLE NEVER WANT TO FIGHT ITS ALWAYS CAUSED BY SOMEONE RICH AND FAR FAR AWAY! Or they’re caused by past events which is like one big ricochet.
Feersumenjinn (2 months ago)
The curiosity for me is it appears the moderate left is increasingly being informed by its more radical elements, leftists often tacitly support their extremist brethren by not challenging extremist rhetoric in their ranks. The focus on fascism is odd considering how unpopular that idea is even within the political right. Nobody wishes to be associated with fascism especially right wingers who work to distance themselves selves from far right extremist ideology. Which of course is why it's such an easy trope for the left to use against them. Weaponised language is a standard leftist tactic of course name calling is common to both sides as we appear to become increasingly partisan across the west. The so called rise of the right across the west in my opinion is not a far right resurgence but a conservative one, as leftist orthodoxy has become mainstream espoused even by traditionally conservative political parties and the media at large the conservative members of society have to move further right for representation as a response to the rather more silly ideas of the left which is currently unchecked. The right wing unchecked descends into nationalist supremacist authoritarianism whereas the left unchecked descends into collectivist authoritarianism, neither of which is desirable and both of which have left a huge pile of corpses in their wake. This current pull to the right I believe to a corrective mechanism to bring society back to the centre ground unfortunately the media is primarily leftist ( in the UK at least ) so the narrative of the right is largely expunged, a dangerous trend forcing conservatives to look elsewhere to less responsible sources for representation. I recommend a return to the middle ground by challenging the leftist narratives and in time the right will take care of itself. Fascism isn't really the issue here for me but radical leftism is,as its refusal to appreciate that 50% of the population are likely to be temperamentally conservative is driving people to the right and with nowhere to go on the moderate right they end up in heading further right than may normally be the case. There was an interesting case I observed recently in the UK where a man attending a right wing political March was interviewed by the media expressed the view that although he wanted to see change he found the views of some on the march distasteful but he had nowhere else to go.
Warren Latham (2 months ago)
Too many confusing fascism and nazi ideology!
Warren Latham (2 months ago)
I think Hitler was laughing at the masses he used them all then attempted to destroy them!
Jilden Davs (2 months ago)
I'm a blue eyed blonde woman and have suffered because of this attitude towards us. Racism.
Jilden Davs (2 months ago)
Have a look at Secret Sources Illustrations watch the documentary that she recommends, she and nine others are fact checking this documentary. She is a retired police detective.
Graham Lyons (2 months ago)
Russell ought to shair some of his hair with Yuval.
terry knowles (2 months ago)
Q. WHAT IS FASCISM ?. the uk national curriculum n schools describes rightly nazi germany as an example. we all agree with that.. BUT it fails miserably to point out that as the Only type.. it fails to even mention soviet union laft wing fascism. .when as we all know Many many more millions died in left wing facisim thsn died in Germanys attempt at facisim.. freedom of thought without being hated and abused for having different opinions is democracy. shutting down others is itself fascist.
Joe OConnor (2 months ago)
UN globalist tyrannical policies spreading across the planet is creating the migration problem part of agenda 21 and 30
justgivemethetruth (2 months ago)
you are not powerful if you are exploited, that is a dumb statement. This is why abortion is illegal and we are programmed and ordered to have children or be looked at askance ... because we must have far too many workers exactly so that workers are not important, and they remain cheap and insecure.
John King (2 months ago)
Russell. Yes, Fascism is back in fashion. You don't think that simple-minded idiots claiming that people shouldn't vote could be anything to do with it. Do you?
grimble (2 months ago)
Yes it is. It has been on the rise since the Bill Clinton / Al Gore administration. Neo-fascism. The old emperor in new clothes. America is about to become a dictatorship. It affects the whole Western culture because America rule. They want to control the world.
anders damin (2 months ago)
Notice how when they speak of a person in general, they always make it a male. This is sexism.
Goose Green (2 months ago)
If antifa is anything to to by it would seem behaving like a fascist is all the rage at the moment
Tim Smith (2 months ago)
If Aldous Snow can't solve our modern dilemma, who can?
Garron Helm (2 months ago)
Is it fascist to highlight the fact you're becoming a minority in your homeland and your culture is being erased? #FuckCulturalMarxism Btw, Adolf Hitler wasn't a Fascist, he was a National Socialist.
G. Spencer Travers (2 months ago)
At about 2:29, Russell demonstrates what the axis of socialist evil actually is. To achieve Hitler's utopia of Aryan dominance, the wealth of those who had earned it- the jews- had to be expropriated and redistributed to those who had not- everyone complicit in the final solution- and this methodology is being extolled by Russell. I don't think I have ever been more disappointed in him.
Gilfoyle Shanks (2 months ago)
Who knew that so many actual Nazis watched russell brand
zyzz (1 month ago)
Whats wrong with National Socialism?
m s (2 months ago)
It is for the left pal .freedom of speach ? The harrassment and ultra quick jailing of Tommy robinson for stateing facts. How much pedaphillia can you stand ?
Adam Stevens (2 months ago)
Excellent point that Fascism is almost always portrayed as ugly and unambiguously evil in both entertainment and school-book history while failing to portray what was so compelling about it for the people involved. There is one piece of entertainment from the last couple of years that did a pretty good job with it, which was Woody Harrelson's character in War for Planet of the Apes. He was clearly dictatorial/fascist, but he was in a position that most people could empathize with to some degree.
trev moffatt (2 months ago)
Anti-Immigration and anti-free trade are not yet fascism. They could be heading toward that ballpark, but they could just mark a return to more paleo forms of conservatism. Which in some ways is worse, at least with fascism, you know what you're up against - you can fight it. And generally speaking it's a short term spasm. Whereas this new Old Conservative order might be around for a long time, might become a permanent fixture. Basically a slow but steady return to the 19th century. Which as I see it, is a by-product of three key developments - Firstly, the revival of more primitive forms of capitalism; secondly, the end of communism, and thirdly, the social engineering engendered by both Liberal and Conservative governments, which endeavoured to increase the size of the petty business class. The Petty Bourgeois being a key social group in terms of reactionary politics.
ANDRES Catella (2 months ago)
THEY WILL FINALLY GET RID OF LABOUR, NOT ANYMORE THROUGH WARS BUT ROBOTICS, FOR THE " VALUABLE, STRONG ONES. NAZIS ARE SERVING ZIONISTS IN THE STREETS AGAINST INMIGRANTS AND ZIONISTS ORGANIZATIONS FINANCE THEM (READ THE GUARDIAN'S ARTICLE).
chester clarke (2 months ago)
the Nazis where/are bad, fascism isnt necessarily bad. one thing that has occurred to me is why did the Germans, where one of the nations most tolerant to Jews in Europe, resort to the ghettos and the holocaust after the great depression. I suspect the German people after falling fowl of the great depression caused by the New York stock exchange then fell fowl of Jewish money lending. you can call me racist but it makes sense. things arnet always black and white who the badies and the goodies are
Mack Mack (2 months ago)
We live under fascism now. Elitist liberalism is about as fascist as you can get. Outside of your upper class bubble Mr. Brand. Politicians are doing their level best to enrage and demean the already beleaguered British people.
Redshift (2 months ago)
https://archive.org/details/EconomicFoundationsOfFascismP.Einzig
Jurij Vukelic (2 months ago)
This bold guy is full of shit. The only way you get power is if you go out of grid and ignore false system. If you ignore it than they don't own you.
Elle A Libre (2 months ago)
Russell, are you morphing into Jim Carey?
Fascism can't be stopped untill people realize that fascism is a natural defence mechanism of herd animals that are under threat.
Tobe Jonsson (2 months ago)
fascism is all about the herd and the direction is pointed kind of like a mob
Tobe Jonsson (2 months ago)
is fascism back in fashion thank you so much for that headline most people don't realize the relationship between Fascism and fashion
clickaccept (2 months ago)
If Hitler had won the war, we'd have learnt a different history, and there would be laws preventing us from questioning it. oh, wait...
Jason Creamer (2 months ago)
If you listen to some Adolf Hitler speeches and disregard the context of his history they really do grip you in a very real way. This is a bit scary because who knows, if someone comes along again who is as determined and charismatic as Hitler I am certain they will easily grip the hearts of millions of the people who feel they have been tossed to the wayside of their society.
Snowy x3 (16 hours ago)
They'll grip all that care for their nation, culture, and people.
daveruda (2 months ago)
So Russel Brand is attracting Nazis and Fascists now? The comment section is like a septic tank. How the fuck did this happen!?
yeah, Brand seams to understand it much better, the thing is that fascism is answering real need and Hariari try to show it as some need for adoration which is something extraordinary in his explanation, but also according to this explanation liberalism is fascist as well, it is much much stronger fascism then what Hitler did in terms of satisfying and creating the need of adoration etc.
ross (2 months ago)
really loved Yuval's book (Sapiens) but I do find he is part of that "nothing really exists except things I like" approach which I really dislike. plus there's some well-veiled foisting of white guilt in that book in my opinion. Would love to see him do a long discussion with Jordan Peterson to see what they talked about inb4 Harari has no issue with ethnonationalist Israel though
DOITLIKETHIS (2 months ago)
I can't believe they are actually discussing what is attractive about facism. It is simple, if you go out of your way to not educate people and a long the way make sure they don't have ways to earn living. If the value of the money as is devalued as it did at the time Hitler came to power it is very easy to feed people glimmers of hope and change and make them believe that the ones that are not like them are the ones responsible as why their situation is a mess. So facism becomes their way out of the situation and that is why they support it
Snowy x3 (16 hours ago)
Hitler wrote it's essential to evaluate taught information with a critical mind instead of mindlessly copying it. He thought the educational system left students with nothing but useless trivialities. He wanted them to focus on firstly, physical, secondly, spiritual (courageous, family values, ...), thirdly, intellectual education. After finishing high school they were supposed to work together for 6 months - 2 years in order to beautify the land and create bonds together. It was part of forming a "people's community". And it tells them that THEY THEMSELVES MUST BETTER THEMSELVES DAILY ... Please, inform yourself because everything you just typed is incorrect: https://youtu.be/7YMG7zDHbew
Jamie Rueffer (2 months ago)
Liberals sound like Fascists. They believe that they are right and beautiful and anyone else is ugly and wrong.
Ban Powel (2 months ago)
Islam is fascism...........sunnis being the most fascist.........12 muslim majority countries presently murder gays and other minorities, plus apostates. But russell dissagrees with that, making russell a fascist enabler.
Ban Powel (2 months ago)
The radical left are fascists, so you could say that fascism has being in fashion for awhile now.
Emyr Iranian (2 months ago)
Is this guy an Israelite ? 🇮🇱

Would you like to comment?

Join YouTube for a free account, or sign in if you are already a member.